Sunday, March 23, 2014

TOK Presentations: What is your Real Life Situation & your Knowledge Question?

The fundamental question of the IB Theory of Knowledge class is How do we know?  We explore different methods and purposes of creating knowledge, weighing their advantages and disadvantages, their limitations and possibilities.  How knowledge is created in a biology class is different from creating knowledge in a literature class.  How knowledge is created in economics is different from how a tribal member knows which medicinal plant to use in a given situation.

Some general questions regarding the construction of knowledge are:

How do we justify our knowledge?  
What is allowed as good evidence?
What constitutes an acceptable explanation?
How do we know which model is the most accurate?
Knowledge questions are at the very center of the class.  An explicit aim of TOK is that the student learn to "formulate, evaluate, and attempt to answer knowledge questions."  At first many students find all this extraordinarily difficult.  Let's take a look at the criteria for Knowledge Questions.

The IB Course Guide gives clear criteria for Knowledge Questions.  They are:
  1. Open-ended questions.  These are questions that have more than one plausible answer.  You must explain and justify your answer.  It does not inevitably mean that a question is irresolvable.  One answer may be more correct than another.
  2. Explicitly about knowledge. 
  3. Expressed in TOK terms.  These are a selection of terms:  Belief, Certainty, Evidence, Explanation, Fact, Hypothesis, Ideology, Interpretation, Judgement, Knowledge, Law, Paradigm, Theory.
  4. Clear in the relationships between these terms
As we begin the first round of TOK Presentations, can we place our Real Life Situations and Knowledge Questions online below?  Please record these by 27 March.

9 comments:

  1. Research Question: what is it about human perception that makes the world around us appealing or not?

    Real Life Situation: Article on the human perception of "cute" taken from national geographic. Exploring how the human brain perceives the world around us.

    By: Max Pregoni, Cristiana Alagna, Cauê Carlvalho
    Grade 11 TOK

    ReplyDelete
  2. Research Question: To what extent can there be knowledge without reason?

    Real Life Situation: Creationism Vs. Evolution debate with Ken Ham and Bill Nye

    By: Marisa Sweeney, Gabriel Negash
    Grade 11 TOK

    ReplyDelete
  3. Research Question: Is Faith a form of imagination
    Real Life Situation: Jehovah's Witness teen loses appeal over life-saving transfusion

    Read more: Jehovah's Witness teen loses appeal over life-saving transfusion

    By: Marco Dietrich, Mihnea Cristea
    Grade 11 TOK

    ReplyDelete
  4. By: Ramzi Shatara, Chiara Vanoli and Balqis Gaddur

    Real Life Situation: An experiment comparing a written conversation vs a conversation solely written in emojis. Which one is more feasible?

    Research Question: To what extent does visual language\symbolic language limit our understanding through communication?

    ReplyDelete
  5. TOK question: Does language effect the way we think?

    Real Life Situation: Stanford University experiment on english speakers and australian aborigenes on ecocentric and geocentric language.

    ReplyDelete
  6. TOK question: To what extent does culture influence perception?

    Real Life Situation: Internet censorship in China, Cuba and Italy.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Beatrice L: To what extent is intuition valid in Mathematics?
    Real life situation: Magnus Carlsen 2013

    ReplyDelete
  8. Research Question : How is Faith proved impossible through Empiricism

    RLS : My (hypothetical) belief in God

    Olly M

    ReplyDelete
  9. Ryo Sasaki + Paloma Laye:
    Knowledge Question: To what extent can language affect our memory?

    ReplyDelete